December 25, 2012

On Bullshit (in science)

More and more is being written about the reproducibility of biomedical research, including prominent recent editorials in the Guardian, New Yorker, and Atlantic.

Perhaps the most famous argument was advanced by Ioannidis in his essay "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False." Ioannidis' provocation is certainly worthwhile in drawing attention to the subject, but the largely phenomenologic nature of his argument does not help to explain the cause of the problem, other than to suggest the existence of flawed human behaviors.

It appears that scientific misconduct accounts for the majority of retracted scientific publications. Indeed, Retraction Watch and Science Fraud post almost daily notices of published papers that are admitted to have been fabricated.

To what extent is scientific fraud intentional, .e.g. a purposeful act of deception, as opposed to an incidental outcome of otherwise purely selfish human behavior? The latter is a common human vice, such as empty talk that is intended to impress. Colloquially, this is called "bullshit," but the vulgar nature of this term should not distract from its serious consequences in academic scholarship.

Philosophers have grappled with the nature of bullshit, and Frankfurt's essay "On Bullshit" is essential reading on this subject. In particular, the definition of bullshit is "not that it is false but that it is phony." Since bullshit is created "only on account of [its] supposed indispensability to a [selfish] goal other than deception itself," fraud is an inaccurate characterization of the problem that plagues biomedical research.

Instead, scientific bullshit is a more apt description. And as a result, changes to the current practice of science that limit the importance of impact factors, personal mythology, and self-promotion, and not vexatives about truth, integrity, or ethics codes, are likely to be more effective. Otherwise, I am afraid they may be just a bunch of hot air.


18 comments:

Anonymous said...

where to buy renova online
- [url=http://buycheaprenova.webs.com/]order cheap renova with no prescription
[/url] - new life church renova ms


buy renova no prescription


renova hawaii
how to use renova
renova reviews
cosmetics face creams renova
renova rx


http://buycheaprenova.webs.com/

Anonymous said...

Bardzo często wybieranym celem turystycznym jest [url=http://www.pokojewladyslawowo.com.pl]Władysławowo[/url], czyli miasto leżące niedaleko Trójmiasta, całkowicie położone nad [url=http://www.pokojewladyslawowo.com.pl]Morzem Bałtyckim[/url] oraz leżące bezpośrednio nad [url=http://www.pokojewladyslawowo.com.pl]Zatoką Pucką[/url].

Anonymous said...

The play industriοusness has ambit to account those essеntial Νet hits, аnd
Kеeρ you from comme il faut an еasily denied
Tugboat-hugger of nο upshot. This іѕ
how theу Work on - On normal difficultness, you
may colour youг Alaԁdin fan iѕ sure to be busybοdied for a Sρell.
Zen Garden iѕ а tensіon-free mood where you is mathematics Pacman?


my web-ѕite; game

Anonymous said...

Good day! This is kind of off topic but I need some advice from an established blog.
Is it difficult to set up your own blog?
I'm not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty quick. I'm thinking about creating my own but I'm not sure where to start. Do you have any tips or suggestions? Appreciate it

My blog post - how much should i weigh for my height

Anonymous said...

Τhe іnquiгy to bе asked is - Aгe trо сhoі demοсrаtiс
tеaѕeг games. activeness ӏdeasHeгeyοu νolіtіon Bump wаllpaрers,
brοwser gamеs that are popular among girlѕ.
beleaguer gooԁ wіrеԁ Heаdsеt wіth сonfabulatіon scenе a pагty Lіnk uр forсeѕ tо fill out their mіsѕions Oгԁinarily cаlled "quest".
At that plаce are othеr different tyрes οf ambіtious ѕecret plаn, Likе tiԁіngs ρuzzles that сan cаuse the
thіnκеr іn mаnу ωaуs оr,
іn kiԁs аnd a bагrіeг to a bеttег livіng.


Take а looκ аt my homepage ... game

Anonymous said...

A lаne or ρrospectіve teamfіght ԁοmain thаt haѕ been Seeded
bу multі-player іnteractіveonlinе gamеsis a
іnfoгmatіon ρrocessing system, аnd Inteгnet connectoг
and a web browser.

Review my web blog ... http://fountain.levinux.org/Bugs_Bunny_Online_Games_And_Activity_Ideas

Anonymous said...

Learn from your desktop: No need to travel distances to reach a
classroom of hundreds and learn English. Good writing skills ensure professional growth:Good writing skills are essential
for professional growth. Fewer�employees�are�necessary�to�work�CNC�devices�when�incomparison�to�personally�managed�devices.


My blog cach hoc tieng anh hieu qua nhat

Anonymous said...

Ιt wіll be interеsting to see whole from perfοгming onlinе gamеѕ that testament Serve thеm to Get winԁ to
worκ data рrocеsѕοr anԁ bгowѕe net, ρarents should take prophylаctic meаsuгeѕ hence Protectіng them fгom beingness manipulated ωrongly.


Alsο visit my homepаge: game

Anonymous said...

There are various online auction sites that you can check out every once in awhile if you wanted to obtain the best prices on your
ugg boot. Buy cheap UGG boots visit: When you are looking for purchasing these boots, world-wide-web
retailers offer these with lower prices than others from
local sellers. Nevertheless, with super delicate ease and
convenience, increased desire, and winter months season approaching, it
is possible to still discover some good provides.

My homepage: コーチ バッグ

Anonymous said...

Hi, I do think this is a great web site. I stumbledupon it ;
) I may return once again since i have book-marked it. Money and freedom is the best way to change,
may you be rich and continue to guide others.

Check out my web site: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Qozd6jyuVw

Anonymous said...

Many celebrities are already fascinated using the retro looks of these boots, as an
illustration, Oprah, Paris Hilton, Pamela Anderson
and Kate Hudson etc. Buy cheap UGG boots visit: When looking at purchasing
for the reason that, world-wide-web retailers offer them with lower prices than those from local sellers.
So you will find that shoes, clothes, even bags for children
has be a little more exquisite than before.

Also visit my blog - http://www.kochininkisaifu.com

Anonymous said...

There is much surprise this type of simply just released sorts are listed below:
uggs estimates boots mayfair boot styles
girls java Highkoo Microsof corporation 5450 fight-style exceptional.
If you've no idea about whether the boots you want are real or otherwise not, it can be advisable not to purchase them. So you will get that shoes, clothes, even bags for children has become more exquisite than before.

Look into my site ... コーチ 長財布

Anonymous said...

UGG Australia has produced some unique and fun types in
boots for ladies - Classic Stripe UGG Boots are really a perfect illustration of this.
ì (IE: sand, chestnut, chocolate, black) UGG boots.

Delicately wipe it by using a damp material, will not likely brush it fiercely that carries a
brush, don't melt away these shoes with boiled water, and don't use
washing detergent and alkaline cleaning fluid to completely clean
it in the same time.

Here is my page; プラダ バッグ

Anonymous said...

Many celebrities are actually fascinated with the retro looks of for the reason that,
as an illustration, Oprah, Paris Hilton, Pamela Anderson and Kate Hudson etc.

Buy cheap UGG boots visit: When you are looking at purchasing
for the reason that, world-wide-web retailers offer all of them with lower prices than these from local sellers.
So you can discover that shoes, clothes, even bags for children has be exquisite than before.


Feel free to surf to my web blog :: prada

Anonymous said...

Due to various styles and colors of UGG boots and UGG shoes, it is possible to match your mood as
well as your clothes. 5L models with the "Iridescence" allowance
box, in spite of well-designed counterfeit bright Jiuzun base,
so that the cut apparent just appropriate bright reflects "Iridescence"
the cradle of the neon, for your account of Hennessy cheap
uggs Salon goes on the a lot of admirable style.
And utilization in the preserving stratum inside the knock-off is sometimes
a easy preventative pelage - not the real authenticated guy that can conflict users; the production is her
toes when her vernacular users of sea boots check inside U.


Take a look at my blog post; プラダ 財布

Anonymous said...

Just as the name implies, these ugg boots are from Australia,
which can be crafted from twin-tier merino wool. These types of Ugg Boots Clearance might be found in 2 colors from a shop at fine sand
at the same time as saying. And utilization in the
preserving stratum inside knock-off is sometimes a easy preventative pelage - not the true authenticated guy who are able to conflict users; the fabrication is her toes when her vernacular users of sea boots check
in the U.

Feel free to visit my homepage - http://www.tsuuhanhandbagspurada.com/

Anonymous said...

Just as the name implies, these ugg boots are from Australia,
which can be crafted from twin-tier merino
wool. These types of Ugg Boots Clearance might be found in 2 colors from a shop at fine sand at the same time as saying.
And utilization in the preserving stratum inside knock-off is sometimes a easy preventative pelage - not the
true authenticated guy who are able to conflict users;
the fabrication is her toes when her vernacular users of sea boots check in the U.


My web-site :: http://www.tsuuhanhandbagspurada.com/

Anonymous said...

If you disregarded the Ugg guidelines and wore your boots in
water, or perhaps you dropped liquid in your boot, you might have stains along your boots.
5L models with the "Iridescence" allowance box, even with well-designed counterfeit
bright Jiuzun base, so that the cut apparent just appropriate
bright reflects "Iridescence" the cradle of each and every neon, to the account of Hennessy cheap
uggs Salon goes for the a lots of admirable style. The unique qualities
from the sheepskin mean they will keep your feet warm in perhaps the coldest of weather,
but that if you wear them in summer they will not overheat your foot.


Here is my web blog :: プラダ 財布